Online Dating Nightmare: A man meets a woman named Tracy on Tinder and agrees to decorate a Christmas tree with her. The encounter quickly escalates into anxiety and fear as the woman's behavior becomes increasingly erratic. The narrator feels increasingly uncomfortable with her appearance and behavior. Strange events unfold as the woman seemingly disappears, leaving the narrator in a state of confusion. The narrator suspects the woman may be older than she claims and may be homeless.

Mystery Santa: A seven-year-old boy and his younger sister experience a terrifying encounter with a man who claims to be Santa Claus. The man repeatedly demands entry into their home, despite their protests and concerns. Children set off a house's smoke alarm to find help, and after a frightening confrontation with the man, firefighters and police intervene, and the man is arrested. The experience highlights the potential danger posed by someone impersonating a beloved character.

Mysterious House: A couple rents an Airbnb during a blizzard for their Christmas vacation. Unsettling events unfold, starting with strange occurrences like the hot water not working and mysterious knocking and footsteps. The couple's sense of unease grows, and they begin to believe that the landlord's brother, a shady individual named Tom, is lurking around their property. They quickly evacuate the dangerous area. This story highlights the dangers of trusting appearances when vacationing away from home.